Posts & Blacklisted by Google – $70M+ Risk

If anyone had any questions, Google is *still* on a mission to squash reputation management firms that use questionable solutions that violate Google’s policies.

Plenty of smaller reputation management firms have been targeted by Google in the past, but Google had upped the ante by completely removing “industry leaders” and from search results. (* as of 4/20/14 – has been re-instated.)

Being blacklisted by Google probably won’t kill either business outright, but for organizations that are in the business of repairing your online reputation it could cause millions of dollars: lost opportunity, public relations fees, and plenty of online reputation management. You can read about Google penalizing other big brands at SearchEngineWatch.

If you didn’t get a chance to spot it in-person live, you can see the results yourself below. The areas highlighted by green are the sections where a site should normally be.


This brings rule #1 in Online Reputation Management to mind:

Only Google can control how sites appear on Google.

If (and when) they choose to prove Rule #1
they will simply remove your entire company from search results.

I.E. blacklisted site only appear when they buy advertising like this:


This is pretty devastating for both companies.

To confirm this wasn’t just a fluke error on behalf of Google I did some research through several tools that tracks natural search results.

The below charts show how many organic keywords (top) and (bottom) had over the last year. showed up for over 1,200 highly relevant keywords and had over 200.

In February and March that entirely changed when they were absent from Google’s search results.


So why should you care?
  1. If you’ve ever expected great healthcare or pulled into a oil shop thinking you’d get out in a jiffy, if you’ve ever relied on a search directory thinking the five star rating meant that you’d actually get something better than at the two star business… you need to keep reading and bring your voice to the conversation.
  2. If you know of someone who is an independent professional or who owns a small/medium sized business, the cost to properly defend themselves against the budgetary and technical power of the involved businesses is exorbitant. This cost could be one you are faced with in the future.
  3. If you’ve ever hired someone or chosen a business because of what you found in Google, this entire process is about controlling your ability to make an informed decision.
State of the Industry

The current problem with online reputation is that we all give away pieces of ourselves to create something bigger than ourselves.

Many of us don’t think about the way our identity and digital information work.

Online reputation and digital scoring is a new and evolving breed of consumer discrimination. This functionality controls the funnel of money into dozens of multi-billion dollar industries that rely on search engines and social referrals.

There are two main categories: individual and business. 

  • Individual identity is being absorbed by platforms like Facebook, Linkedin, and Twitter. Our e-mail and phone conversation more accurately describe us than most of our actual in-person introductions do. This score controls how many people get my information and how those people initially react to me.
  • Business or group identity is being (or has been absorbed) by entities such as Google and Facebook. Even as a business owner myself, the act of having a company brand is contaminated by the very essence of how Google and Facebook portray that business. Business scoring affects multiple individuals and has significant impacts on strategic partner revenues, employee hiring, and stock/brand value.

This is such a large and lucrative market that my company is tracking hundreds of vendors who deal with reputation management, brand monitoring, and social media engagement. It is almost impossible for the average web user to understand the layers of discriminatory judgement that are being applied to them every time they search for information.

Why does that matter?

Having our digital identity owned and curated by a profit seeking entity creates an unusual problem for both individuals and businesses: the roar of the voice gives way to how good and honest people traditionally function.

Very few of us are built to promote ourselves 24/7, and the most prominent individuals online are either self-promoters or simply have too much money.

The honest business and professional usually gets left behind by these two groups. Businesses like Google look to turn this data into corporate profits, and service firms such as and act as middle men that cater to our desire to present ourselves as professional.

What is this worth?

Reputation and brand is a priceless commodity that Google makes an insane amount of money on when people search for the name of a person or a business entity.

According to Crunchbase, has been funded for $67.7M from firms such as Bessemer Venture Parnters, Kleiner Perkins, and Jafco Ventures. is privately funding to the tune that last year it rebranded itself from Reputation Changer to (and paid $500k for the domain.) and both sell services ranging from $1000 to ‘the sky is the limit’ – Business services exceed $100k a year.

The Spider Effect

In the eyes of Google every item links to another source of data.

All of these elements tie together to form an impressive algorithm that considers page rank, author rank, linking sites, types of content, historical relevance, trending news, etc.

When Google blacklists a site it can see all of this interconnected data and it can assign penalties to everyone involved that it considers to be in violation of policy.

If we just look at one data point with the number of links pointing to each domain, it means that there are thousands of sites in the review process.

Using a tool to examine links (Majestic SEO) – we can see that there are 149,936 links pointing at coming from 5,993 unique domains and that has 61,696 links coming from 1,027 unique domains. By reviewing page and directory structures across sites we can also conclude who is and isn’t a client of different services.

This highlights thousands of customers across the services that may suffer

  • increased reputation problems
  • decrease to all organic search engine optimization
  • numerous crisis communication issues
  • client association and reputational risk

Check out Part II – Why Would Google Blacklist and
– where I will dig into some of the details of why Google could be targeting these services.

About the Author

I’ve been in online reputation management since the beginning of the concept. In 2002 I launched a domain service  that was specifically tailored to executive reputations (through, which now just acts as our agency domain registrar) and since then I’ve technically orchestrated massive search engine optimization platforms, created multiple reputation and brand based tools, and have dug deep into social media monitoring. Eventually I moved my understanding of digital presence frameworks to serve as the foundation of doing cyber security, influencer analysis and competitive intelligence.

I now spend a majority of my time working with my team on digital strategy projects for corporate and venture funding endeavors. I tend to be deep in thought as I try to answer the question of “what is this data worth?” and “where does this data go?” – my current focus includes handling a fairly massive cyber security project and figuring out how we are all going to live in the matrix (you can read my bio here or connect on Linkedin.)


Map Test

[TS-VCSC-Google-Maps maptype=”OSM” mapstyle=”style_blue_water” coordinates=”47.603569, -122.3294525″ metric=”false” markerzoom=”17″ mapfullwidth=”false” breakouts=”6″ mapfullwrapper=”false” directions=”true” controls_pan=”true” controls_zoom=”true” controls_scale=”true” controls_street=”true” controls_style=”false” markerstyle=”default” markeranimation=”true” markeranimationtype=”drop” margin_top=”20″ margin_bottom=”20″][/TS-VCSC-Google-Maps]
[TS-VCSC-Youtube content_youtube=”” content_lightbox=”true” content_youtube_trigger=”winged” content_youtube_image_simple=”false” content_image_height=”height: 100%;” content_youtube_iconsize=”30″ content_youtube_iconcolor=”#cccccc” content_youtube_buttontext=”View Video” content_youtube_title=”Awesomesauce” content_youtube_subtitle=”Amazingly kewl” lightbox_play=”false” lightbox_group_name=”nachogroup” lightbox_effect=”random” content_tooltip_css=”false” content_tooltip_position=”ts-simptip-position-top” margin_top=”0″ margin_bottom=”0″]

enterprise social platforms

[TS-VCSC-Icon-Counter icon_position=”left” icon_replace=”false” icon=”ts-awesome-stack-overflow” icon_size_slide=”100″ icon_color=”#25ea88″ icon_frame_thick=”3″ icon_frame_radius=”ts-radius-full” icon_frame_color=”#000000″ padding=”false” icon_padding=”5″ counter_value_start=”10″ counter_value_end=”46″ counter_value_size=”60″ counter_value_color=”#000000″ counter_value_format=”true” counter_value_plus=”true” counter_seperator=”false” counter_note=”Tools Counted” counter_note_size=”12″ counter_note_color=”#000000″ counter_speed=”2000″ tooltip_css=”true” tooltip_content=”Suggest another tool! Use the form on the right ->>>” tooltip_position=”ts-simptip-position-bottom” tooltip_style=”ts-simptip-style-blue” animation_icon=”bounce” margin_top=”0″ margin_bottom=”0″ icon_background=”#ffffff”]
90 - Social Collaboration Tools

Enterprise Social Monitoring

Enterprise Social Marketing

Enterprise Social Compliance

Recommend a Tool

If you have a tool you think should be on this list, just drop me a quick link here:
42351420064Enterprise Social CollaborationSocialcast is the enterprise social platform that connects people to the knowledge, ideas and resources they need to work better together.
63607640132Enterprise Social CollaborationFind out why more than 100,000 businesses and government organizations use Huddle for enterprise content collaboration.
1186270191Enterprise Social CollaborationJive is the communication and collaboration platform for modern, mobile business.
37631650018Enterprise Social CollaborationYammer is a leading enterprise social network for businesses to get work done smarter and faster. Sign Up Today.
315121100106Enterprise Social CollaborationMicroblogging for sharing with colleagues. Instantly see what colleagues are sharing for a snapshot of what’s going on in your company at any given moment.
300891740077Enterprise Social MarketingWildfire provides powerful, easy-to-use social media marketing tools for pages, messages, ads, promotions, monitoring, analytics and more.
7502470057Enterprise Social MarketingStrengthen your social media management with Spredfast, the leader in enterprise social media platforms. Our SMMS delivers hard statistics for your company.
276283459240087Enterprise Social MarketingEnhance your social media management with HootSuite, the leading social media dashboard. Manage multiple networks and profiles and measure your campaign results.
791214050Enterprise Social CollaborationAs the Enterprise 2.0 leader, Socialtext applies Web 2.0 technologies such as microblogging, enterprise social networking and wikis to the critical challenges facing businesses. Socialtext's enterprise collaboration platform allows employees to share expertise, speed workflows and get their jobs done faster.
614686030127Enterprise Social CollaborationConnect everyone everywhere. Connect everyone everywhere. Manage conversations across social networks, websites, and mobile devices.
0000121Enterprise Social CollaborationEmpower your workforce, stay connected and be more productive with enterprise social collaboration tools and HR self-service solutions from Sitrion
487720086Enterprise Social CollaborationMillions of users globally rely on Atlassian products every day for improving software development, project management, collaboration, and code quality.
178430091Enterprise Social CollaborationZimbra powers modern collaboration for the mobile era, connecting people and information with a unified communications software platform that combines traditional and social collaboration.
150083Enterprise Social MarketingSecure and scalable business unified communications solutions delivered by Unify, formerly Siemens Enterprise Communications.
95600063Enterprise Social CollaborationWrike is web based project management software that gives you full visibility and control over your projects. With the help of our product you can do online project management, time tracking and project planning in the most effective way.
7210071Enterprise Social CollaborationClaromentis Intranet Software - business, collaborative and social intranet applications & Learning Management. Try the free intranet demo or request a quote.
192000122Enterprise Social CollaborationeXo Platform, open source enterprise social platform for business portals and social intranets complete with collaborative and content management features.
20116250103Enterprise Social CollaborationZyncro is the most flexible social business platform that offers you a new way of working: collaboration, integration, mobility
0000153Enterprise Social CollaborationNeudesic is the trusted technology partner in business innovation, with a proven track record of delivering effective business technology solutions.
9726710136Enterprise Social CollaborationSaba is a leading provider of Learning Management (LMS), Talent Management, Performance Management, and Cloud Collaboration Software Solutions.
18977021Enterprise Social CollaborationOffiria is a full featured, Open Source Enterprise Social Network and intranet software for your team or business. Successful companies Work Better with Offiria.
806358021Enterprise Social CollaborationSharetronix
149042017Enterprise Social CollaborationHoney is a simple and beautiful enterprise social network for news sharing and non-urgent communication.
53222061Enterprise Social CollaborationMangoApps uniquely combines Enterprise Social Networking, Online Collaboration tools, Task Management and Intranet pages into one breakthrough product. MangoApps is one of the few services that gives you the flexibility to choose how it is deployed within your organization – Shared Cloud, Private Cloud or on-premise (behind your firewall). It’s up to you.
7502470057Enterprise Social MarketingStrengthen your social media management with Spredfast, the leader in enterprise social media platforms. Our SMMS delivers hard statistics for your company.
27811048Enterprise Social CollaborationIBM SmartCloud for Social Business provides enterprise-grade file sharing, communities, web meetings, mail and calendar for any organization.
67772039Enterprise Social MarketingSocial CRM: Social Media + Customer service = socially-connected business. As social media continues to grow, customer service needs to influence the customer experience. Learn more about SCRM and customer engagement with Salesforce Social CRM.
010051Enterprise Social CollaborationAffordable Web based CRM Software for managing organization-wide sales, marketing, customer support, and customer orders in a single system. Free for 3 users
17843830091Enterprise Social CollaborationZimbra powers modern collaboration for the mobile era, connecting people and information with a unified communications software platform that combines traditional and social collaboration.
4301155617037Enterprise Social MarketingArgyle Social is marketing software made for the social B2B. We integrate with several marketing systems and social networks to ensure your social data is relevant at every level of your organization.
9902969810143Enterprise Social MarketingSprinklr offers the only Social Media Management System that enables global scale for the social enterprise.
6256255640055Enterprise Social MarketingSprout Social is a social media management tool created to help businesses find new customers & grow their social media presence. Try it for free.
466670049Enterprise Social MonitoringInfegy's social media monitoring and analytics platform is trusted by brands, agencies, and researchers to deliver accurate, in-depth consumer insights
130324020057Enterprise Social MarketingShoutlet is an independent enterprise social relationship platform that works with large companies to prove return on social through an increased focus on integrating social data into business, scaling social across the enterprise, and helping brands build relationships that build business.
10874620639078Enterprise Social MarketingSendible is a social media management, monitoring & analytics tool to help businesses find new customers & manage their social media presence. Try it for free.
186226641023Enterprise Social MarketingSocial Media Management Software to Enable Customer Relationships.
1220152073Enterprise Social ComplianceSmarsh offers a unified platform built for compliance and e-discovery. Learn more about our enterprise archiving solution.
38052050Enterprise Social CollaborationJostle’s People Engagement® software engages employees in ways traditional intranet software never could. Our simple, cloud-based intranet connects people and aligns teams across organizational silos and boundaries.
607150028Enterprise Social CollaborationAn online service to create, customize, and share a social network.
26783351036Enterprise Social MonitoringSysomos is the leading provider of social media monitoring and analytics tools. Features include Sentiment Analysis, Workflow Management, Facebook and Twitter integration.
4049086069Enterprise Social MarketingGaggleAMP is the social marketing platform that lets companies Amplify their social media reach by leveraging individual employees, customers and partners. Using GaggleAMP, companies are able to widely distribute their content and messages while they Analyze the results and Align their social media spend to where the ROI is.
000040Enterprise Social CollaborationIntellum's full-featured enterprise social networking tool encourages social learning and facilitates collaboration for distributed teams. Read more now.
600081Enterprise Social CollaborationOracle Social Cloud allows you to improve employee engagement and collaboration across the organization with pervasive, social capabilities.
0000134Enterprise Social CollaborationSee the full list of Cisco collaboration products, including Unified Communications, Customer Collaboration, Collaboration Applications and TelePresence.
1205000255Enterprise Social CollaborationSharePoint is about giving you and the people you work with a better way to get things done together. Browse through these scenarios to discover what SharePoint is and what's in it for you.